The Fifth Reel
The Odyssey art
Theaters · Review

The Odyssey

Home(r) Run
5/5
By ·

History is not without its share of called shots. Joe Namath guaranteed a Super Bowl. Larry Bird wanted to know who was coming in second. JFK looked at the moon and gave NASA a deadline.

We do these things not because they are easy but because they are fucking awesome.

Fresh off a perfect season with Oppenheimer, Christopher Nolan announced his intention to take on the biggest story ever told. All he needed was a quarter of a billion dollars and half of Hollywood. The atomic bomb was this guy’s warm-up act? Sounds like somebody intent on adding his name to that catalog of cowboy shit. But after a setup like that, can he deliver the prestige?

Saddle up, Tonto. You’re not going to want to miss this.

The spoiler embargo on The Odyssey expired a few thousand years ago, but let’s get the big one out of the way for those of you who learned the definition of truancy at a young age: this is the story of a guy who takes a long time to get home.

Nolan keeps his version true to the traditional telling and starts right near the end. Odysseus (Matt Damon) has been gone for twenty years. Things back home are tense, both because that’s a long time to be gone and because word has long made it back that the war he went to go fight has already been won. His son Telemachus (Tom Holland) has nearly come of age in that time—he was a baby when Odysseus left—and dudes are literally lined up to marry Odysseus's wife Penelope (Anne Hathaway) so that they can become king of Ithaca. Telemachus is sure that his dad is coming back but doesn’t know what to do about the suitors, so he heads out to Sparta to get some advice from Menelaus (an excellent Jon Bernthal). While he’s gone, the sleaziest of the suitors Antinous (Robert Pattinson) decides to shoot his shot, and then tells his boys to shoot Telemachus when he returns.

But what’s taking Odysseus so long anyway? Well, he’s encountered all manner of bad traffic on the way back. With the war won and Troy already having suffered enough from Agamemnon’s senseless conflict, Odysseus decides to wing it on provisions and head straight home. Just a few pit stops, guys. Unfortunately, those stops include a cyclops’s cave, a beach in the territory of literal giants, and the house of a woman at that stage of her pottery journey where she turns every man who comes to her door into a pig. Not exactly a man with a career writing for Frommer’s in his future.

If all that sounds like a lot for one man to bear, it is, and Nolan brilliantly uses the scale of his epic as an essential piece of his narrative, with each new gargantuan spectacle vital in how small it allows his hero to become. The mind that helped bring down Troy belongs to a man increasingly burdened by what that victory cost—and how much of the price he left others to pay. And as each new challenge rises to imperil Odysseus’s hopes to get his remaining men home, it only adds to a reckoning that began long before he set sail. Damon lets the shame accumulate delicately but relentlessly, quietly eating away at the legend. He’s firing on all cylinders in a time before they even had them.

Across the ocean, Hathaway’s Penelope must stake everything on the man she remembers, with no way of knowing what remains of him. Memories nearly twenty years old sustain her as she fights to preserve a home for his return, her options for protecting their son and kingdom narrowing with every delay. Beneath all that resolve, Hathaway lets us feel Penelope’s fear that she has mistaken her need for Odysseus to be alive for a reason to believe he is.

To say that Nolan makes it all work is the understatement, not just of one century, but of several. His command of the story is richest in how much weight the journey accumulates without losing momentum. Every ordeal carries the pressure of what is waiting in Ithaca—a wife running out of options, a son exposed to danger, a kingdom that may no longer be his when he returns. That emotional tether gives the spectacle its urgency and makes each delay painfully significant.

When all is said and done, nearly three hours disappear into a story about a never-ending trip home—an extraordinary feat of storytelling that lets us feel the cost of those twenty years without feeling the length of the movie. One hectic trip to the bathroom later and you might even be left entertaining the ridiculous possibility that he undersold the thing.

Nolan called his shot and fucking nailed it. As for Best Picture, I’d like to know who’s coming in second.

← Back to reviews