The Fifth Reel
Heartland art
Streaming · Review

Heartland

Law & Opry
3/5
By ·

It only takes a minute or two for Jessica Chastain to don the felt Stetson that her Misty Jones wears for most of Heartland’s runtime. With Chastain under the brim, I’m not anticipating a cattle shortage. And if you’re not picking up what I’m putting down, the hat isn’t going to be doing the intimidating. It’ll just be what everybody describes to the paramedics.

True, the opening scene—sans hat—does its share in feeding this suspicion about the livestock. The former country star shoots out her neighbor’s windows after an argument about a dog. Like all of ‘em. From there, Misty doesn’t seem to have much love for anyone without paws, requiring quite a bit of arm-twisting from her brother before she’s willing to go looking for her missing niece Charlie Heart (Carter Faith), a rising star in no-good Nashville.

Early efforts to go through the proper channels don’t go smoothly. Misty’s reputation precedes her, and the police seem to wish the rest of her hadn’t followed. Their publicly available notes describe her as the “queen of mean.” Misty prefers the cunt of country. Whatever stage name we’re going with, it sounds like she’s going to have to run this operation herself.

Call me the king of let’s fucking go.

Needing to drum up a little support, Misty immediately appears on a talk show and fills the audience in on just how pulpy this little square dance is going to be from here. Turns out Misty is Charlie’s biological mother. That revelation is enough for the cops to let Misty into Charlie’s house, where they find the bloodstained carpet and troubled, unfinished lyrics this movie needs to land squarely in its genre. With record executive Roy Combs (Garrett Hedlund) and old friend Buck (Ben Dickey) in her corner, Misty gets to work.

As the cast starts rolling up its sleeves, Heartland starts whipping itself into one frenzy after another, and you begin to worry that every revelation will be more interested in its own fireworks display than in building toward something. Luckily, Chastain knows how to settle the movie back into Misty’s search without surrendering the urgency of whatever fresh hell has just broken loose and a few early melodramatic turns don’t give way to the film spiraling into a groan-inducing brand of pulp. The script deserves its share of the credit, too, for recognizing when it’s found something worth slowing down for, and that purposeful restraint becomes more apparent as the middle act comes to a close.

Once we can all see where this back road leads, the script doesn’t spend an eternity pretending we’re still lost. The final act commits more fully to keeping everything in check, declining to bleed us dry waiting for the ultimate reveal once we all know what we’ll be revealing. A few charming scenes exploring Misty’s rivalry with Winnie Jo Lean (a superb Jennifer Nettles) get more room to breathe than the final showdown, which is as quick and painless as the baddie is obvious. And getting the investigation out of the way leaves time for a tender scene with Misty’s ex-husband Clark (John Hawkes) and gives Carter Faith some actual screen time before the movie overstays its welcome.

None of this takes Heartland to the depths Chastain is capable of reaching, but a movie that could easily have squandered this cast gives them something worth doing. The musical performances feel like a natural extension of the characters and their histories, adding personality to a mystery that gets by largely on attitude without turning the whole thing into a country episode of Glee. The film gets to be both pulpy and tender by trusting its cast to make a few well-crafted scenes count—and by leaving time for the aftermath instead of chasing suspects until the cows come home. The result is 114 minutes that go down easy.

For all the hell Heartland raises, it knows when to tip its hat and leave.

← Back to reviews